Everence Federal Credit Union names Matthew Gehman as new President/CEO

Banking |

Credit union thanks outgoing president, W. Kent Hartzler, for years of service

Matt Gehman and Kent Hartzler, Everence Federal Credit Union

Matt Gehman (left) will succeed Kent Hartzler (right) as President and CEO of Everence Federal Credit Union, effective April 1, 2021.

The Everence® Federal Credit Union Board of Directors has appointed Matthew Gehman to lead the organization and succeed W. Kent Hartzler, who served as the credit union’s President and Chief Executive Officer since 2007. The transition will occur on April 1, 2021.

Gehman first joined Everence in 2015, most recently serving as the credit union’s Chief Lending Officer. In making this transition, Gehman will also serve as a member of the Everence Senior Leadership Team.

“Matt’s skills and capabilities have been important to our successful management of credit union products and services,” said Shirley Hochstetler, Chair of the Everence Federal Credit Union Board of Directors. “With his experience and understanding of our members, Matt is well-positioned to lead the credit union into a new chapter of growth and innovation.”

Previously known as Mennonite Financial Federal Credit Union, the organization affiliated and rebranded alongside MMA (Mennonite Mutual Aid) to become Everence in 2010 – bringing together their collective, comprehensive faith-based financial stewardship services for individuals, organizations and churches. The rebranding symbolized the company’s desire and intent to become a new organization for future generations, putting faith into action to walk alongside members regardless of racial, ethnic, gender or socio-economic backgrounds.

“Our credit union services are key to achieving our vision to building stronger relationships with our increasingly diverse member base,” said Ken Hochstetler, President and CEO of Everence Financial (no relation to Shirley Hochstetler). “We look forward to Matt’s additional contribution as a member of our Senior Leadership Team, as we further align efforts and resources to help members integrate their faith and finances.”

W. Kent Hartzler, outgoing President and CEO of Everence Federal Credit Union is stepping down to become a Lead Consultant with the North Group in Lancaster, Pennsylvania.

“Under Kent’s leadership, our banking services have grown to the largest they’ve ever been, surpassing $285 million in assets in 2020 with record deposit growth and business loan production and expanded to include 20,000 members in all 50 states and more than 25 countries,” added Ken Hochstetler. “We wish him well in his transition and thank Kent for his dedicated service to Everence over the years.”

Prior to Everence, Gehman served in various regional banking roles, including credit analyst and commercial relationship manager. Gehman is a graduate of Eastern Mennonite University (Harrisonburg, Virginia), and lives in Lancaster with his wife, Samantha, and two children.

About Everence

Everence helps individuals, organizations and congregations integrate finances with faith through a national team of professionals. Everence offers banking, insurance and financial services with community benefits and stewardship education. To learn more, visit everence.com or call (800) 348-7468.
Madalyn Metzger


Madalyn Metzger
Vice President of Marketing

Become a Member

Making a difference, together

At Everence, we believe it's possible to incorporate your faith and values with your decisions about money. Take a closer look at the difference it makes when your financial services company is rooted in something more than making a profit.


Learn more