Common misconceptions about Medicare

Be ready with accurate information before you sign up

Older woman playing pickle ball

Medicare decisions are some of the most important choices you’ll need to make in retirement – yet many people make them based on myths, assumptions or advertisements promising low-cost plans and flashy benefits. Making the wrong Medicare decisions when you’re eligible can have extremely costly consequences in the future.

One of the biggest myths is that the lowest premium plan is automatically the best deal. Medicare Supplement plans often come with higher monthly premiums but lower out-of-pocket costs and more predictable expenses. Medicare Advantage plans may offer low or even $0 premiums, but members can face significantly higher costs when care is needed.

Another common misconception is choosing a plan based only on your current health. The best Medicare plan should support your needs, not just at 65, but far beyond. Healthcare needs often increase with age, making long-term coverage flexibility especially important.

Provider access is another major difference many people overlook. Medicare Supplement plans allow you to see any provider or facility that accepts Medicare. Medicare Advantage plans typically rely on provider networks, and out-of-network care can become expensive quickly – especially for frequent travelers or seasonal residents.

Many people also believe they can easily switch between Medicare Advantage and Medicare Supplement plans later. In reality, moving to a Medicare Supplement plan after your initial enrollment period may require medical underwriting and coverage can be denied.

Finally, the best plan for a friend or family member may not be the best plan for you. Medicare decisions can be extremely personal, and reviewing your individual goals and lifestyle with a specialist can help you make a more informed, long-term choice.

About the Author


Bayley Stauffer, Financial Representative
Bayley Stauffer
Financial Consultant

We're here to help

Finding the Medicare insurance plan that suits you best can be confusing. Everence can offer clarity and walk alongside you every step of the way on your Medicare journey.