Medicare supplement insurance

Get health coverage from a member-owned, Christian organization dedicated to helping its members. Participate with others who share your values.

Where do you live?

Insurance costs vary by location. Tell us your state so we can help you better.  If you can't find your state, contact Everence.


Why get a supplement plan?

Medicare won't cover 100 percent of your medical costs during retirement. An Everence Medicare supplement plan can help you with those expenses that Medicare doesn't pay for. Everence® will help you decide if a supplement plan is right for your situation.

Why choose Everence

Pondering together

Personal service

Work with a representative in a local office or at our national call center who can guide you now in your Medicare decisions – and all through retirement.
Man holding a piggy bank

Affordable costs

You can choose from a range of competitive and affordable plans to fit your budget and needs.
Couple laughing while looking at flowers

Individual and community benefits*

As an Everence Association member, you are eligible for benefits, such as a wellness benefit and will preparation benefit. We also have a Sharing Fund, a community benefit that helps people in need.


Representatives are all licensed insurance agents of Everence. Insurance products are offered by Everence, the marketing name of Everence Association, Inc., a fraternal benefit society, 1110 N. Main St., PO Box 483, Goshen, IN 46527.

Medicare supplement insurance plans offered by Everence Association, Inc., a fraternal benefit society, are not available in all states, and are not connected with or endorsed by the U.S. government or the federal Medicare program.

This is a solicitation of insurance and an insurance agent or insurance company may contact you in an attempt to sell you insurance.


In Colorado, all Medicare supplement standardized plans are offered to Medicare qualified individuals due to disability regardless of age.

In Florida: This policy has exclusions, limitations, and terms under which the policy may be continued in force or discontinued. For costs and complete details of the coverage call (or write) your insurance agent or the company.

*In Idaho: Individual and community benefits are not insurance, they are part of being a member in Everence Association, Inc.

In Maryland: Plan A is available to under age 65 Medicare-qualified individuals due to a disability.

In Oklahoma, Plan A is 2105239 OK, Plan C is 2105240 OK, Plan F is 2105241 OK, Plan G is 2185050, Plan L is 2105242 OK, Plan N is 2105243 OK.